Back-to-School Daze
What to do when your child protests returning to school.
by Stephen W. Randolph, Ph.D.
PARENTGUIDE News September 2005
Transitions
are difficult for pretty much everyone. From a holiday
then back to work, or between leaving the demands of
the office for the demands at home, you’ve probably
heard colleagues, friends, loved ones or yourself lament,
“I need a break from…”
Consider then— without an adult’s maturity
level, past experiences and learned techniques and defenses—
how much more difficult it may be for our children to
handle transitions. From a summer vacation to the beginning
of a new school year, from weekend freedom to Monday
morning rigidity, even the daily awakening from the
comfort of home to return to several hours of scheduled,
disciplined routine in a place where a need to listen
and attend prevails, as does having to perform and be
judged academically, it’s no wonder some kids
may protest when it comes to returning to school. Here
are some ways to deal with children’s complaints
and help make school a more inviting place:
One of the first items to heed when your child complains
is to listen to his or her reasons. Try to distinguish
with your child’s help if the problem seems primarily
physical (stomachache), academic (test anxiety), social
(self-esteem issues) or something strategic (avoiding
bullies on the bus or taunting in the classroom). Determining
the cause or merely getting a hint of your child’s
angst can avoid future complaints and help solve the
problem.
Explain to your child the importance of attending school,
and keep your child in school! Try to avoid setting
precedents for missing school other than for illness
and the institutionally-sanctioned times off—
weekends, holidays, teacher conferences and inclement
weather days. The more you allow your child to miss
school, the more the child will “need” to
stay home. Not only are you avoiding the root of the
problem, you are encouraging your child to avoid routine,
of regular school attendance and of any school attendance.
As important as maintaining regular school attendance,
is not forcing a debilitated child to go to school.
When your child complains of physical symptoms, and
especially if school resistance is a behavioral or emotional
change, schedule an appointment with the pediatrician.
Regardless of whether your child’s complaints
have a medical etiology or are psychosomatic, your child’s
physician should be aware of the problem and make a
note in the child’s file.
This way, the physician can coordinate the care of your
child among various professionals. If it seems your
child’s complaints are of a psychogenic nature,
the pediatrician can most likely recommend and refer
you to a competent therapist who specializes in family
and children’s issues. It’s of great value
for your child’s psychotherapist to know that
medical causes have been ruled out. You may visit such
a clinician before seeing a physician, but you will
find that a psychotherapist will probably advise you
to also rule out the need for medical intervention.
For children whose school record includes a history
of academic and/or behavioral problems, or if you’re
able to determine your child’s resistance as related
to academic or behavioral issues, consider requesting
a psycho-educational assessment to account for any learning
disabilities. Such an assessment can be conducted by
a school-based support team through the Board of Education
or by a psychologist in private practice. Your child’s
teachers will be a good resource for advice in this
area.
Unfortunately, it’s all too common for parents
and sometimes administrators to consider a child “lazy,”
“stubborn,” “recalcitrant,”
when in fact the child may have a neurologically-based
learning disorder. Broadly, a learning disorder could
be blindness, deafness or paralysis. More narrowly,
and often less easily recognized, a learning disability
could be a problem with perceptual-visual-motor coordination.
Disorders of attention and hyperactivity lie perhaps
midway on the spectrum of recognition. Also, not to
be neglected are problems of an emotional nature, such
as any of the affective disorders of depression or anxiety.
These may be noted by your child’s pediatrician
or teachers. A social worker, psychologist or psychiatrist
can then further assess the problem to prescribe the
appropriate intervention.
For all the above academic/behavioral problems and more,
help is available through various professionals in the
fields of education, social work, psychology and medicine.
Use them. Let them do their work. Allow them to share
their expertise with each other and with you, and ask
them for their recommendations.
If your child has complaints of school, almost inevitably
homework will be included. After a day of structured
and supervised school activity, your child should have
a break upon arriving home. Allot for 30-60 minutes
of relaxation time of the child’s preference.
Afterwards, and until dinner time if necessary, homework
should be worked on. Break for dinner; and homework
continues after meal time as long as necessary until
bedtime.
With the exception of your child’s initial break
time to unwind after school, homework should be done
before any other play or recreational activity, including
the telephone. The built-in reward for completing homework
in a timely manner is that recreation may fill whatever
time remains before bed. Where possible, try to save
family chores for weekends. Your child’s primary
responsibility from Sunday through Thursday is school
and homework. Play runs a close second. Play is one
of the ways children develop psychologically.
Different children demand different degrees of attention
and help with homework. If school frustrations continue
to arise, a clinician specializing in work with families
can help define the nature and amount of help needed
and the manner of delivery most beneficial to your child
that’s also possible for you, given your own responsibilities
and stress level. Your primary responsibility as a parent
is to provide the structure, as in the expectation of
work before play, as well as the time, space and material
for homework.
By bedtime, even if your child has not finished homework,
spend a short time (ten-15 minutes) with him. Acknowledge
any of his or her disappointments at the end of the
day of which you are aware. Sympathize without promising
a cure. Do your best to find something positive directly
related to your child that you can comment on, take
note and compliment. Remember you can compliment effort
even if the performance results or the child’s
frustrations with school were less than stellar.
Regarding school behavior problems, a general guideline
is to have the school discipline your child. Remain
in touch with the school and aware of any trouble your
child stirs. If you do not agree with the discipline
that the school deems appropriate, discuss with the
appropriate school personnel to hopefully reach an agreement.
Given that, you should be supportive of the school.
You should not impose a secondary level of punishment
at home for in school behavior. Again, let the school
do its job. You may inform your child of your disappointment
and concern, however, do not double team your child
with your disapproval.
When children complain of school, many parents, with
the best intentions, attempt to talk their children
out of their thoughts, beliefs and feelings. Do not
do this. Do not try to convince them that “things
are not so bad after all,” or that “it will
be better than you anticipate.” Don’t debate
with them, either. Instead, acknowledge and validate
their feelings of reluctance, fear, regret, anger; unfairness
of the world, teacher or even you, the parent. Even
if you disagree, let your kids know that you hear their
dissatisfaction. You might even convey to them that,
given their description of the situation, you can understand
why they feel the way they do. Then brainstorm with
them for compromises and possible solutions. You can
also do this if you’re skeptical of the scenario
and complaint your child presents. Helping them to solve
or ameliorate a situation, even something you’re
skeptical of, teaches children how to take responsibility
for their thoughts and feelings.
To that end, recognize and accept your limitations as
a parent by not trying to do more than you are expected
to do. You provide the groundwork and the atmosphere
in which your children have the opportunity to thrive,
encouraging them to thrive in the classroom as well.
Actively participate with professionals in various areas
of your child’s lives. But remember, you can not
and are not supposed to know it all. You may unashamedly
seek advice for getting to the root of complaints and
helping your child cope with transitions. Then let your
children grow into who they will become at school and
out in the world.
Stephen W. Randolph, Ph.D. is a
clinical psychologist who maintains a private practice
on Manhattan’s Upper West Side. Dr. Randolph’s
specialties include work with children, adolescents
and families. He may be reached for professional consultation
at (212)724-8838.